Jurik Research (http://www.jurikres.com/) has an excellent version of these types of indicators called RSX. When I was trading forex for a while at night, I used RSX in combination with the JMA, and it helped a lot with with upswings and downswings. The problem with RSI and %R is that they are very jittery and prone to false signals. RSX seemed to be less prone to false signals, and helped out a lot.
One of the experiments that I did because I was tired of trying of re-installing the Jurik Indicators each time I upgraded computers, and because I wanted to try to use indicators with my own custom trading software was trying to reproduce this type of indicator on my own. One of the things that I tried first was a truncated FFT, essentially using a lowpass filter. Woila! Instant success. While not exactly the same as the JMA or RSX, it produced results close enough to use for trading.
Great blog! I did some analysis with RSI 50 on the S&P. Very interesting check out the image http://i26.tinypic.com/2mphfeb.jpg
ReplyDelete